Rontheoldwiseeagle
Active member
The fans have packed it in for this year. Their dozen tailgaters have packed the gear and stored it away. There is not single topic post for this weeks game with the Eags. In fact, not even a post from Screamin_Eagle174 to ruffle their feathers. :lol: The longest and most attactive topic is Next Years team.
Here are a few posts from this topic.
I wonder how much interest the team has in the game? They did put up some numbers in the second half again the MSU bench last week. There are nine of us caravaning down. I sure hope we will be able to get tickets
by VikThunderous » November 11th, 2012, 4:32 pm
jas wrote:After today, I can't decide between two much different thoughts about the Viks:
1) A lot of freshman from the much heralded recruiting class got to play and get experience this year. Burton is a heck of a recruiter, and there seems to be a positive culture. A lot of key contributors are going to be back and, like the tv guy said today, they have the ability to really surprise people next season like Northern Arizona did this year....
Or
2) Record wise, they really aren't much better than they were under JG. In three years under Glanville, they won 7 Big Sky games. In three years under Burton, they have won 8. The momentum of one of the country's biggest turn around seasons seems to have left with Kavanaugh, McCaffrey, Shead, Rau, Waldron, etc. And, after next Saturday, they will no longer have Monahan, Jackson, Sluss, Brown, Lewis, etc.
What are your thoughts on the Viks next year?
No one can be blamed for being frustrated. The team underperformed. Win-Loss record is the bottom line and we haven't made any improvement under Burton. I think this program could go either way at this point depending on the next two recruiting classes. And recruiting only gets a program so far. Burton needs some help coaching.
I can't think of any coaches that go 2-9, 7-4 and then drop to 3-8 that are ultimately successful. Montana State went 6-5, 7-4 and 7-4 in Coach Ash's first 3 years. Maybe someone can show another example of a team regressing so much in the 3rd year that succeeded?VikThunderousWalk On Posts: 191Joined: June 24th, 2008, 4:56 pmFavorite School: PSU
Top
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Your thoughts on next year?
by GreenGiant » November 11th, 2012, 4:36 pm
I think one of the biggest problems going into this year was no emotional leadership on either offense or defense. Each side of the ball needs their leaders. Last season I think it was pretty obvious that there were some guys that really stepped up to fill those important roles. I never got the feeling this year that there was one guy that could pull the others aside and get things turned around.
The offense should be fine. We have enough key players returning that there shouldn't be a step back.
We will need to try and replace some key players up front, and at linebacker. Sluss may be the most difficult player to lose to graduation on the field. We are graduating a bunch of DB's, but as hard as the current guys have worked on every play, I just don't think we could get much worse in this department. Frankly, I blame as much of this on the coaching as I do the actual players. Burton better be spending as much time recruiting a coach as players in this regard.
It seems like the last two games we kind of took a step back and that is a little concerning. If KM was hurt coach should have pulled the trigger earlier and given one of the other QB's a shot.
Either way, I don't think that anyone that takes the time to post here is giving up on anything. I think maybe we all started the season with our rose colored glasses on, We didn't realize just how young we were going to be at some key positions.
GreenGiantHigh-Quality H20 Provider Posts: 21Joined: July 27th, 2012, 11:17 amFavorite School: Portland State
Top
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Here are a few posts from this topic.
I wonder how much interest the team has in the game? They did put up some numbers in the second half again the MSU bench last week. There are nine of us caravaning down. I sure hope we will be able to get tickets
by VikThunderous » November 11th, 2012, 4:32 pm
jas wrote:After today, I can't decide between two much different thoughts about the Viks:
1) A lot of freshman from the much heralded recruiting class got to play and get experience this year. Burton is a heck of a recruiter, and there seems to be a positive culture. A lot of key contributors are going to be back and, like the tv guy said today, they have the ability to really surprise people next season like Northern Arizona did this year....
Or
2) Record wise, they really aren't much better than they were under JG. In three years under Glanville, they won 7 Big Sky games. In three years under Burton, they have won 8. The momentum of one of the country's biggest turn around seasons seems to have left with Kavanaugh, McCaffrey, Shead, Rau, Waldron, etc. And, after next Saturday, they will no longer have Monahan, Jackson, Sluss, Brown, Lewis, etc.
What are your thoughts on the Viks next year?
No one can be blamed for being frustrated. The team underperformed. Win-Loss record is the bottom line and we haven't made any improvement under Burton. I think this program could go either way at this point depending on the next two recruiting classes. And recruiting only gets a program so far. Burton needs some help coaching.
I can't think of any coaches that go 2-9, 7-4 and then drop to 3-8 that are ultimately successful. Montana State went 6-5, 7-4 and 7-4 in Coach Ash's first 3 years. Maybe someone can show another example of a team regressing so much in the 3rd year that succeeded?VikThunderousWalk On Posts: 191Joined: June 24th, 2008, 4:56 pmFavorite School: PSU
Top
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Your thoughts on next year?
by GreenGiant » November 11th, 2012, 4:36 pm
I think one of the biggest problems going into this year was no emotional leadership on either offense or defense. Each side of the ball needs their leaders. Last season I think it was pretty obvious that there were some guys that really stepped up to fill those important roles. I never got the feeling this year that there was one guy that could pull the others aside and get things turned around.
The offense should be fine. We have enough key players returning that there shouldn't be a step back.
We will need to try and replace some key players up front, and at linebacker. Sluss may be the most difficult player to lose to graduation on the field. We are graduating a bunch of DB's, but as hard as the current guys have worked on every play, I just don't think we could get much worse in this department. Frankly, I blame as much of this on the coaching as I do the actual players. Burton better be spending as much time recruiting a coach as players in this regard.
It seems like the last two games we kind of took a step back and that is a little concerning. If KM was hurt coach should have pulled the trigger earlier and given one of the other QB's a shot.
Either way, I don't think that anyone that takes the time to post here is giving up on anything. I think maybe we all started the season with our rose colored glasses on, We didn't realize just how young we were going to be at some key positions.
GreenGiantHigh-Quality H20 Provider Posts: 21Joined: July 27th, 2012, 11:17 amFavorite School: Portland State
Top
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------