Putting sports above all else at my alma mater puts NAU right in line with those shitbags in the SEC (the "southern" football conference...not the Securities and Exchange Commision...though I'm sure they'd irritate me if I furthered my research).
Expecting minimum academic requirements and bending on decisions regarding "character" at the FCS level leads to the kind of shit storm that is currently going on in Missoula. NAU had similar grade and behavior issues in the mid-late 90s. It sucked. I don't want it again.
I will agree to disagree overall on this topic with you, jacksdude. But I do think NAU has the mix right at the moment as the players are doing well on and off the field.