Cub,
Maybe I can shed some light on part of the exodus occurring. Look at three of the kids that have left this Spring. Clint Brock, Ben LaPorta, Nick Tramner. Not sure about Nick, but he has been fighting injuries the last couple seasons, but had the heart of a lion. Why leave now? Ben and Clint left for Academic reasons, but not the usual kind. Both were concerned about their Academic performance and felt they were not getting suppport from the coaching staff. Clint was concerned that, being recently married, and only on a partial scholarship, he would need some slack in conditioning and workouts so he could work and study. Whitworth was fairly obnoxious to him, so he quit. Ben had several instances when he went to Whitworth with concerns about classes and was told he was sweating his Academics too much. Two illustrations. Prior to the Weber State game last year, Ben was concerned about a Psychology test he had the day before the game. He asked Whitworth if he could get off early from practice one day so he could study. Not only did he not get any time off, he got royally chewed out, and was held out of the Weber game until cleanup duty in the fourth quarter. Just a couple of weeks ago, he went in to talk to Whitwoorth about his feelings for the upcoming Spring ball. He was again told that he sweated his Academics too much and that it didn't matter if you graduated with an A or a C, the diploma was all that mattered. This is the kind of attitude players concerned about Academic performance are getting from some coaches.
As far as the other Academic problems, I understand there were 38 kids on the D and F list this Spring. I can see why therre are so many if the coaches' attitude with regard to Academics is to do only enough to remain eligible and no more. There is no room for error and some of these guys need all the help they can get. Look at some of the Academic non-performers who will hurt the team when it comes to APR. Kenny Visor, Jeremy Gibson, and Sengal and Taylor if they decide to leave.
Despite appearances, I believe the coaches care only enough about Academic to keep players eligible, and that attitude is coming home to roost. They are losing players at both ends of the spectrum.