• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts, upgrade to remove ads and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your BigSkyFans.com experience today!

A Grip On Sports: EWU’s football season has been historically awful. But we can envision a strong last couple weeks and a tough decision ahead.

Regardless of who the coach is next year, I think the season is most likely a wash. If it's Best, I'd have a hard time believing he can take a team to above .500. If it's a new coach, it's sort of the same thing, although they may have better odds of recruiting some players out of the portal than could quickly narrow the gap in talent between EWU and the top conference teams.

Personally, I'm looking towards 2028. Phase I of the stadium project will be completed, and that's definitely something to look forward to. I hope continued improvement will translate to better recruiting, better results on the field, and winning back the crowd.
 
Regardless of who the coach is next year, I think the season is most likely a wash. If it's Best, I'd have a hard time believing he can take a team to above .500. If it's a new coach, it's sort of the same thing, although they may have better odds of recruiting some players out of the portal than could quickly narrow the gap in talent between EWU and the top conference teams.

Personally, I'm looking towards 2028. Phase I of the stadium project will be completed, and that's definitely something to look forward to. I hope continued improvement will translate to better recruiting, better results on the field, and winning back the crowd.
Same. Either next year's a complete rebuilding year, or the next one.
 
I think the talent is there for the most part just not the coaching. The right coaching staff using the portal to shore up certain positions. 5 or 6 maybe 7 wins is doable. But yea we ain't going to the playoffs or anything.

Need someone to actually coach up Schakel when Bell transfers to Montana and makes it to the semi finals.
 
I thought about it some more, and I wouldn't even care if we went 0-12 next season with a new HC if it meant we had measurable improvement in the next couple of years. Right now we're not even stagnant, we're regressing in every metric. W/L, attendance, fund-raising. I'll always be an Eag, and I am grateful for the totality of AB's service to the program/school/community, but a change in leadership should be the AD's primary focus from now until a new hire is made. Get the funds for the buy-out, and get it done, Collins.
 
AD needs to sit down with Best and hear what his plan is for immediate improvement, and what is required from the AD to make it happen. If that plan isn’t concise, reasonable, and immediate… you part ways.

I hope Collins has already done his homework and knows what’s available on the market. The dumbest thing to do is can Best with no real plan forward. A new coach needs to also have a plan for immediate improvement, and have a way to get (or bring with him) players that can make it happen.

There are so many issues with this team that it’s gonna need to be a comprehensive fix… a total rebuild from ground up. Whoever is leading that needs to be capable of doing a lot of work and find the resources to do it.
 
I think the talent is there for the most part just not the coaching. The right coaching staff using the portal to shore up certain positions. 5 or 6 maybe 7 wins is doable. But yea we ain't going to the playoffs or anything.

Need someone to actually coach up Schakel when Bell transfers to Montana and makes it to the semi finals.
You’re seeing something totally different than me. The coaching has been wretched, but I’m not seeing many guys that’d even be on the two-deep ten years ago. We don’t have the horses anymore.
 
AD needs to sit down with Best and hear what his plan is for immediate improvement, and what is required from the AD to make it happen. If that plan isn’t concise, reasonable, and immediate… you part ways.

I hope Collins has already done his homework and knows what’s available on the market. The dumbest thing to do is can Best with no real plan forward. A new coach needs to also have a plan for immediate improvement, and have a way to get (or bring with him) players that can make it happen.

There are so many issues with this team that it’s gonna need to be a comprehensive fix… a total rebuild from ground up. Whoever is leading that needs to be capable of doing a lot of work and find the resources to do it.
Bro, we're way past that. If Best hadn't been around the program since the 90s he'd be gone years ago.
 
The Big Sky is much deeper than it was during the glory years but that still doesn't excuse this seasons record. The Utah Tech game for last place in the Big Sky was closer than it should be. Idaho destroyed us and won't make they playoffs. Next year will be rough regardless of who is the coach but I have seen enough of Best and would like to give someone else 4 years to see if they can turn it around.
 
You’re seeing something totally different than me. The coaching has been wretched, but I’m not seeing many guys that’d even be on the two-deep ten years ago. We don’t have the horses anymore.
Bell is technically has the 12 most passing yards in the FCS. Garrett, Carlson and Branch and been catching most of those throws. They've made some pretty good catches from what I've seen. Competent play calling and those might actually translate to wins. Not to mention our QBs coach has ZERO experience playing QB.


There are some studs on defense, Perez, Mayovsky, Jenkins, Marsh, Voigtlaender. Our DC is literally in his first year of being a DC. I don't think he was even co-DC before.

I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of them transfer if Best isn't let go and a good HC isn't hired.
 
The part I’d emphasize is this isn’t just a coach issue, the AD needs to step up too.
Bell is technically has the 12 most passing yards in the FCS. Garrett, Carlson and Branch and been catching most of those throws. They've made some pretty good catches from what I've seen. Competent play calling and those might actually translate to wins. Not to mention our QBs coach has ZERO experience playing QB.


There are some studs on defense, Perez, Mayovsky, Jenkins, Marsh, Voigtlaender. Our DC is literally in his first year of being a DC. I don't think he was even co-DC before.

I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of them transfer if Best isn't let go and a good HC isn't hired.
Maybe some of those guys make the 2016ish two-deep, but that’s it. The talent is far lower than where it was a decade ago.

I don’t think firing Best and trying to win next year without a significant talent upgrade is going to help. If Best goes, the next guy needs a way to bring in better talent. Ideally, he’s a guy who already has kids ready to move.
 
I'm sure everyone on here is ready to contribute to NIL fund
Its crazy some of you think we need NIL to compensate for Best's and company's shitty coaching.

You can waste your money on him. I'm going to wait for a coach that makes the team better not worse.

How much NIL money do you think Idaho State gets? And yet they have 7 wins, a win over FBS Utah State and almost beat Montana State. Weber State sitting at 8 wins, NAU at 9 wins. None of these schools get a lot of NIL money yet they seem to win and some if not all are going to the playoffs.
 
Last edited:
"And that momentum will help them win the season finale Nov. 21, when Portland State (2-8, 2-5) travels up the road to Cheney for the Dam Cup."
 
Watched the the YOUTUBE highlights of the game this morning just to see what the attendance looked like.
Didn't see one single shot of the west side of the stadium. The north end zone looked like it had 20 people at the most, sad. I think Eastern is becoming the new Portland State.

I'm sure AD Collins would like to move forward with the hiring process but his hands are tied until he gets the green light from his boss. When Collins came in the best thing he did was cut off Best's contract extensions. In this day and age of college coaches jumping ship I think the yearly contract rollover extensions just handcuff the university more than anything. Maybe Collins has the green light to start the process and has already put out feelers for a new coach. If so, that's leadership taking a proactive move to right the ship. Does the president have that kind of leadership qualities? I have my doubts, more likely the administration will just ride it out for another year, hope I'm wrong. After looking at next year's schedule Eastern will have another 8 or 9 loss season. I would rather see it under a new coach building the program back up instead of going for a ride on the Titanic.
I wonder how long it will take to hear either way on Best's future.
 
Back
Top