• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts, upgrade to remove ads and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your BigSkyFans.com experience today!

Bubble Watch and Selection Sunday

the dan

Active member
I wanted to start a thread as we are just 48 hours from Selection Sunday. If we win, we are in. The question is, can we secure a Top 16 seed and home game? The dream scenario is probably the 13 seed, meaning we wouldn’t be in Montana State / Tarleton / SDSU’s immediate bracket.

Using Herder’s Bracketology as a baseline, here is where things stand going into the final week:

Teams guaranteed to be seeded higher than us:

1. Montana State
2. Tarleton State
3. South Dakota State
4. Lamar
5. Mercer
6. SFA
7. Northern Arizona
8. Youngstown State
9. North Dakota
10. Illinois State
11. Tennessee Tech
12. South Dakota


Teams in contention for seeds 13-16:

Austin Peay - 8-3, 1 ranked win, No. 39 SOS. They are 11.5 point favorites on the road vs Central Arkansas

Montana - 8-3, 2 ranked wins, No. 14 SOS. They are 8.5 point underdogs on the road vs Montana State

Lehigh - 9-2, 1 ranked win, No. 89 SOS. They are 10.5 point favorites on the road vs Lafayette.

Harvard - 8-1, 0 ranked wins, No. 88 SOS. They are 6.5 point favorites at home vs Yale.

Monmouth - 8-3, CAA Champ, 1 ranked win, No. 76 SOS. They are 3.5 point underdogs on the road vs Campbell. I don’t think Monmouth would be placed higher than Weber, but it’s possible as a conference champion.

Weber State - 7-4, 3 ranked wins, No. 19 SOS. We are 17.5 home favorites vs Utah Tech.


Herder has the final seeds as:

13. Austin Peay - I would have us ahead of Peay. They only have 1 more win than us and it’s vs a much weaker schedule.
14. Weber
15. Montana - I expect the committee to have Montana ahead of us as long as they don’t get blown out this weekend. We’ve seen the Griz get preferential treatment from the committee plenty of times.
16. Lehigh - I’m a little worried the committee would put Lehigh ahead of us. Yes they’re schedule is weak, but 10 wins always gets some respect. They have an ugly loss vs Cornell, but our loss to Portland is worse.


Finally, I don’t know what to think about how we stack up vs Harvard. Their resume really isn’t impressive and Ivy is weak this year, but it’s still a respected conference and they showed well in the playoffs last year. Plus, rating systems love them - SP+ has them ranked 9th in the FCS.

My prediction: we win tomorrow and get the 15 seed.
 
I’m thinking they may be a 13 seed. The SI article seemed to think Wildcats were a lock to host a playoff game if they win this week. They are playing impressive right now…that might overcomes the early losses.

Wonder if Coach Kjar went to the 6A Championship game to see his youngest son play today. Corner Canyon won a thriller 45-44.
 
Getting a home game is great, but it's the playoffs. Win and keep playing, lose and get ready for Christmas break. No matter where you play or who you are playing, you prepare the same way as always. Coming out of the BSC, you have played a lot of tough games. No difference now. Everyone you could possibly face will be good.

The other thing I like about a home game is that I might be able to attend it.
 
Honestly with all the losses ahead of us (certainly Austin Peay) we could break into the 12th seed. Would have helped to have a more dominant victory today. Hard to punish Tennessee Tech for losing to an FBS team. Montana will still probably be seeded higher because of $$$. Why should we be rated lower than NAU? Their win today wasn’t overly impressive either. Either way let’s keep playing.
 
Just for fun, here’s my best guess for tomorrow. Never done this before.

1. Montana State
2. Tarleton State
3. South Dakota State
4. Lamar
5. Mercer
6. SFA
7. Youngstown State
8. South Dakota

9. North Dakota
10. Northern Arizona
11. Tennessee Tech
12. Montana
13. Weber State
14. Lehigh
15. Illinois State
16. Austin Peay


Last 4 in:
UIW
Bryant
UC Davis
Idaho State

Unseeded Autobids:

Harvard
Monmouth
Long Island
Dayton

And my guess for our first round opponent: Incarnate Word.
 
Would’ve rather had the 13 or the 15, but it is what it is.

Can’t say I’ve seen Western Illinois play this year so I have some research to do.

SP+ isn’t updated yet, but based off last weeks rankings we would be a 1 point underdog. Massey would have us as a 4-point favorite. All that really matters is how well we protect the ball IMO.
 
Back
Top