I’d like to see Carmazzi redshirt, particularly given the 2-3 soph QBs Sac will have going in to '08. (I would have preferred for Duncan White to RS too last year as he was pretty green.)
From ESPN’s recruiting site on Carmazzi…
“Carmazzi is a perfect fit for the west coast offense where his height and lack of arm strength can be masked and his accuracy and ability to get rid of the ball on time can be maximized. He has quick feet and is an above average athlete for a pocket passer. He shows a quick drop and set up and is at his best when he can dink and dunk and be sure of his first read. Release is adequate and he can get ri dof the ball quickly. Is most effective when working the middle of the field in the short-to-intermediate zones and when rolling out so he can see the field a bit better. The problem with Carmazzi as far as the Division I level is concerned is his lack of height and arm strength to stretch the field and fit the ball into tight spots. Does not show much zip on his throws and if he is late of off balance he will struggle to make throws to the sidelines. He is a QB prospect with redeeming qualities.”
http://insider.espn.go.com/ncf/recruiting/tracker/player?recruitId=53161&season=2008