Coach Mental definitely knows the game of football. He has been successful in the past and did a good job as the OC in Hill's last year. With that being said, being an HC for a DI team is a bit different than where he was before. He might have been the only real choice Coach Crompton had or the only current assistant who would take it. Can't say it was true or not, definite hearsay. Yet, the word on the street was players were going to leave if the coaching staff did not stay intact. A new coach from outside, even a former Hill coach, would have wanted full reign over his staff. Inevitably, some of the current coaches would not have been retained.
After Hill, no matter who took over, they were going to face a tall task. To me, I would have tried to get someone who was as much like Jay as possible: Charismatic, professional, understands the importance of recruiting local, while getting gems from out of state, is dynamic and experienced on multiple levels. Jay is an incredible defensive coach. He is also really good with special teams, team management (player and coach development), and recruitment. He finds the overlooked, underappreciated, gems. The Jack Kelly's come to mind. Never would Jay have shown up wearing joggers, a hat and a sweatshirt to an event; especially the Big Sky Football meetings. He looked the part, acted the part, and was always professional. Mental...he doesn't act the part. I definitely want him to succeed. I want him to develop as a coach and person. I hope he takes that next step. Yet, as of right now, the trend isn't going in the right direction. After almost two years, the program is started to smell a little stale.