Oldhornet23 said:
Let's not compare a HS coach to college.
Why not? You do realize that a lot of successful college coaches came via the HS route? Look no futher than Gus Malzahn, currently Auburn's HC, who was a long time HS head coach and Jeremy Pruitt, who just won a National title as Florida State's defensive coordinator. Pruitt's defense last season was ranked in the top 3 in the Nation in every major statistical category.
Point is, a coach should not be overlooked simply because they've only coached in HS (Btw, Taylor does have 5 years assistant coaching experience at the D1 FBS level). I just cited two recent, relevant examples from BIG time D1 FBS programs. There are many, many more out there.
Oldhornet23 said:
Not one of those Folsom QB have been successful when they left.
That's not entirely true. Cary Grossart has enjoyed a fairly successful career at NAU. We have no idea yet how Jake Browning is going to turnout at Washington, but he's certainly been Taylor's most sought after recruit. Even Alabama recruited him. And you're not even considering all the non-Folsom, local area QB's he has tutored over the years.
Regardless, you're missing the point. Taylor took undersized kids, such as Dano Graves and Tanner Trosin, and developed them into elite HS QB's that landed D1 scholarships. The fact that they've yet to make a mark at that level doesn't matter. It's a testament to Taylor's coaching ability that he was able to get them to overachieve beyond their physical limitations. Every QB he's coached at Folsom has landed a D1 scholarship. That should tell you something. The guy knows how to develop QB's .. Pure and simple.
Oldhornet23 said:
Plus when they do play De la sale they get smoked.
Again, what does this matter? De La Salle has been smoking every single NorCal team for the past 22 years. They haven't lost even one game during that time (247-0-2). Since 1979, that program has only lost 26 games period (413-26-3). The game they lost last December to snap a string of 4 consecutive Open State Championships came at the hands of a St. John Bosco team that many insiders claim to be the best HS team that SoCal has ever produced.
Troy Taylor is among a myriad of great coaches and players that haven't been able to solve the De La Salle puzzle. That's in no way a knock on his abilities.
Oldhornet23 said:
He is a good coach but from Folsom HS to college could be much and just because you played in NFL for a little while doesn't mean anything.
Correct, playing in the NFL doesn't at all mean that you'll be a successful coach .. even at the HS level. But having a successful college career at a big name school, as well as playing in the NFL, does give Taylor some experience and insight that not every coach has. What you also don't seem to be aware about is that Taylor was a graduate assistant at the University of Colorado in the mid-90's and an assistant coach at Cal for 4 years in the late 90's. He has D1 coaching experience at prominent programs.
Couple that with what he's done at the HS level and you come up with a qualified candidate. That's all I'm saying.